Stereotypes of non English Speakers


Amy Tan’s article “Mother Tongue” discusses various issues that is present even in our current society and one of them being the stereotypes made against non-native English speakers.

Native English speakers are better English speakers and all in all smarter than non-native English speakers. This tends to be a common misconception in our world today and let me just say that this is absolutely bogus! The fact that this delusion continues to be present in our society is a psychotic way of misleading non-native English speakers to fulfill their full potential and passion. The prejudice and stereotypes branded on nonnative English speakers is relatable for many people across the world and from personal experience, I can say that it ain’t a good feeling.

Schools oddly enough can be a prime example of this fallacy. This isn’t just about students discriminating against non-English speakers but teachers’ making assumptions on the capabilities of non-English speakers and how some schools choose to advertise their English teachers as “native speakers”.  In Amy Tan’s article, she explains an academic stereotype on how in school, teachers tried to steer her and other Asian students to math and science due to better achievements in those subjects, which is helpful but it also begs the question as to why they weren’t aided in English more. Could it be because of their limited English.
There was an advertisement intended for learners of English as an additional language in Jordan and it said, “Our teachers are all qualified native speakers”. What does it mean to be a native English speaker? Well in a nutshell it is someone’s primary language for communication that they have grown up with. I am a native Tamil speaker but there is no way in hell that I could teach it to someone because I’ve only used it in a non-standardized way and lack the skills needed to educate people.
Can’t this be the case of native English speakers as well? I am from Australia and practically everyone speaks English but whilst in school there I have heard my native English-speaking friends say stuff like “more better” and “open the light” and used improper apostrophes and commas. Native speakers make mistakes as well and that’s completely fine but what discombobulates me is that these English mistakes paired with certain accents are held against nonnative English speakers.  A non – native English speaker with right qualifications can be just as adapt at teaching English as native English teachers. 

Now if you are a stubborn banana you might be wandering why I’m ranting on about this but try to picture yourself in these non-native English speakers’ shoes. Knowing very well of their limitations of English and thus making felt even weaker because of society’s hard judgments.  How weak they might feel to not even be able to properly communicate and how these set-backs can affect people by not finding jobs or pursuing their goals which is a right everybody should have. 

Comments

  1. Anonymous1 October 2017 at 23:17

    This was a very solid blog post, highlighting how stereotypes impact non-native english speakers lives. You demonstrated your personality by using words to support opinions one would use during a debate, and it helps the claim of the blog. The blog post is still relevant as many people still don't speak english. You used a lot of examples we as normal people could relate to. This also made us think of ourselves and how we act with non-native speakers. I completely agreed with the fact that teachers in public schools often steer students towards another subject when the other gets to hard as I have seen it first hand. One question I have however is, how you think these stereotypes were created? That would be very interesting. On the other hand, I would try to identify a call to action as I really didn't understand what you were trying to achieve besides make us think about the stereotype. A few more statistical facts would have been good support, but all in all, this was a very interesting and informative blog post! :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Unknown2 October 2017 at 08:38

    This was a very interesting blog post, well done :) Your topic is clear - being how non-native English speakers are assumed to be less smarter than those who are native English speakers (as well as going into how that is seen in school) - which you find is 'bogus' haha. I like how you've used native English speakers (your Australian friends) as an example that, although making mistakes is okay - that together with an accent that non-native English speakers have affects the perspective of others of them. I think it's definitely newsworthy because it touches on a topic that we tend to not notice most of the time, or we do but we just brush it aside. Not to mention, there are people around us who can't speak English well enough and want the support. What you're doing in this blog is making people aware and to empathize with non-native English speakers who are being highly affected in their lives due to not being a native speaker. Adding in statistics will definitely aid your opinion if you want your readers to think what you're writing is credible. Last thing, now that you've made your readers aware... What are we supposed to do about it? :))))

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

MLK-Speech

MLK's intended audience through his speech " I have a dream" are the African- American community but more specifically those that are living through oppression, suffering from segregation and discrimination, and whom are living in poverty. MLK tries to persuade the African American Community to continue to fight even if the nation goes into turmoil and to only stop fighting once the black society has gained racial equality and justice. In addition, MLK tries to  spread hope to his fellow African - Americans by intensifying their frustration and anger to provide a sense of empowerment, in the hopes of advocating and creating change in the American Society. MLK often uses metaphors and anaphoras to enrich his persuasion. His expressive choice of phrases such as " chains of discrimination" and "let freedom ring" are examples of rhetorical devices which were used throughout this speech. His style directly correlates to the racial tensions which occurred
Read more
Image
My interests include playing many different sports but my favourite sport is soccer. I love listening to different styles of music especially rap, hip-hop and punk rock.  My hobbies include collecting badges and patches. Language plays an important role in my life because my mother tongue is Tamil and often my parents talk to me in Tamil and since this is my mother tongue I feel that it is important to be able to speak it since it ties me more to my cultural heritage. Its also the easiest way for me to express myself and feelings. I think that it is important to study language because I belief that you should have a better understanding of the language you are speaking and because language is the most common and widespread form of communication and yet I personally don't know much about how important and powerful language can be. I haven't felt excluded due to language barriers because even in Malaysia I was still speaking English with my parents and went to an English me
Read more

Single Parents and Non-Marital Births

How could the text be read and interpreted differently by two different readers? The news article titled "For women under 30, most births occur outside of marriage" was an article which highlights the phenomenon of non-marital births and single parenting within the United States. In news media, the information communicated can vary between each individual depending on the context of a reader and their ideologies. In this article, textual bias is evident to demonstrate the author's negative notions towards single parenting and having children before or without marriage. This is evident through the author's choice of diction of words with negative connotations such as illegitimacy and normal being used in the same sentence to show frustration towards the topic. An individual with a traditional ideology of having kids after marriage and opposed to the idea of single parenting would resonate with this text. On the contrary, individuals with a feminist ideology will rea
Read more